Pink bird review April 2017 Etude House eyeliners

Etude House Super Slim Proof Pencil Liner in Black

Etude House super slime eyeliner

Background

0.08g (not a lot of product there)
Two colors black and brown

Ingredient analysis: Skincarisma

Etude House super slime eyeliner

My thoughts on Etude House super slim proof liner in pencil

This pencil is really thin and I feel that it is quite hard to work with just because the pencil is so thin. When applied on the waterline it is not completely black, more grayish and I do feel that it is not very smooth.

Etude House super slime eyeliner

I very seldom use a black liner, since my eyes are hooded It can sometimes look like I only wear eyeliner it I use the black once. But I do use them mainly for tight lining for a fuller look of my eyelashes. When I use black eyeliner I really want it to be black and not gray.

Etude House super slime eyeliner

This is not a pencil that you can smudge, it dries really fast but still it transfers if you blink before it is completely dried. This doesn’t last at all, but at least better than the brown one. It does last longer in my waterline than on the lid so after two hours the eyeliner was almost gone on top of my lid, but it was still visible on my waterline.

I give this product 1/7

Etude House super slime eyeliner
Swatch Etude House super slime eyeliner Brush liner to the left and pencil liner to the right

Etude House Super slim proof brush liner in Brown

Background

Two colors, black and brown
0.6 g

Ingredients

Ingredient analysis: Skincarisma

Water, Acrylates Copolymer, Iron Oxides, Methylpropanediol, Beheneth-30, CI 77266, 1,2-Hexanediol, Alcohol, Butylene Glycol, Pentylene Glycol, Bis-PEG-18 Methyl Ether Dimethyl Silane, Sodium Polyacrylate, Steareth-20, Phenoxyethanol, Laureth-21, PVP, PEG-40 Hydrogenated Castor Oil, Allantoin, Ethylhexylglycerin, Sodium Dehydroacetate, BHT

Etude House super slime eyeliner

My thoughts on Etude House super slim proof liner brush version

This was a total disaster for me. I usually use Clio´s eyeliner and I have been really happy with that. This one was acting really weird and I am not sure if it was my copy that was acting weird or if this is how they are.

My first problem was application, it doesn’t seem that the brush transfers much liner at all on my lid so I really need to go back and forth a lot to be able to even see anything at all. When comparing the strokes with Clio it seems like the color doesn’t work with the brush or at least there is such a small amount of product on the brush that it simply doesn’t transfer. If you wait a while between the strokes it works a little better.

I took some pictures to compare the Clio waterproof brush liner and this one and the amount of product on the applicator is really different.

Etude House super slime eyeliner
Comparing Clio kill with Etude House super slime brush liner, the upper one is Clio and the lower one is Etude House

When I finally got a result, I was happy with it seems like it doesn’t last at all on me. It lasted approximately two hour then it was almost completely gone.

I do have little oily eyelids but no eyeliner has ever acted like this on me before.

Other reviews in the April box

Pink bird, Etude House honey cera sample kit first impression
Pink Bird review, Etude House fix & fix tone up primer in mint
Etude House Pink Bird April 2017 unboxing so far looking good

Where to get it

Ebay (for sellers I recommend visit my online shopping post)

Jolse

Pencil liner
Brush liner

I give this product 0/7

I’d love to meet you on Twitter so follow me here or if you prefer Instagram, you can follow me here.

 

**Disclaimer: This blog contains both affiliate and non-affiliate links. By clicking on an affiliate link, I receive a small commission (from the company I am in affiliation with, not you of course) which goes to keep this blog to support itself. For more information see disclaimer and contact.

Related Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *